Sunday, 19 May 2019

noise - Ground plane directly underneath physically large 100 µH inductor?


I plan to use a physically large ferrite core inductor (Murata part "1410478C", 100 µH at 1 kHz) in a 12 V, 7 A DC filter circuit. It will be mounted on topside of a four-layer PCB (from top down: top routing, split GND plane, split PWR plane, and bottom routing).


It will be filtering typical DC input from a car's 12 V system, which can be a fairly noisy environment. The circuit has transient suppression and reverse voltage protection nearby.


I am not sure what to do with the ground plane directly beneath the inductor's physical location. My instinct is to back-off the perimeter of the GND plane so that it is not close to the EM field surrounding the inductor.


There are two GND planes on layer 2, one called "VEHICLE_GND", which surrounds all the input filtering components, and another called "0V" and provides GND connections for the 3.3 V digital systems which are unrelated to the filtering. The two GND planes are connected at a single point by a through-hole zero-ohm link. Star grounding has been used throughout the design.



Is my instinct right in this instance or would it be better to allow my VEHICLE_GND plane to cover the area underneath the inductor? I would be concerned that ripple from the car's electrical system might be directed through the inductor and cause the VEHICLE_GND plane to exhibit the same ripple probably at a slightly lower amplitude.


Any guidance would be welcome.



EDIT...


I have accepted Oliver Street's excellent answer and have decided to remove the GND plane beneath the inductor (also suggested by Peter Smith) as it does not form a hole in the plane in my case due to the inductor being crammed into the corner of the PCB. However had the removal caused an enclosed hole to form (and quite a large one) I would be less inclined to perform the removal. The PCB has not yet been manufactured, and I still have an opportunity to perform some measurements on my selected components, now that I have some idea what to look out for.


Here's a rough sketch of the position of the GND plane and the inductor for the curious.


Enter image description here



Answer



Before you read the bit below about the ground plane, I suggest you read the Murata-Erie data sheet again. If you're using the 1410478C choke at 7A it's already nearly saturated and the inductance has fallen to something like 70% of the value without a DC bias. (see the Murata footnote) There are other parasitics that may or may not make any difference to your application that won't be on the data sheet. You can have a closed magnetic path bobbin wound choke if its made on a pot core, E-core, etc and you can still have and air gap in the center post to control the saturation point. I think you should either ask Murata about that choke's internal topology or consult a belt sander near you.


I can say from experience the ground plane doesn't screw up a simple lowpass DC filter, with a typical pi topology. Opening a hole in the ground plane always turns current noise into voltage noise, of course. Assuming you want more than vague assurances.



The inductor is being used as a high AC impedance, presumably with some capacitors on each end as low AC impedance. The AC current in the choke is intended to be as small as possible, but if the PWB ground plane (and case cover) are contemplated as coupled then the concern would be that it behaves as coupled inductors with the shorted one being around 20nH (as an informed guess from the choke's dimensions) with a mutual coupling coefficient somewhere under 10 percent (another informed guess). If you crank the numbers I think you'll find secondary inductance is so low that the current in the shorted turn (the ground plane current) is negligible and the induced voltage even more so, at any frequency where the 100uH choke's interwinding capacitance didn't short it out anyway. This is not a system noise source.


If you are trying to filter anything other than automobile alternator and ignition noise, filtering topologies for higher frequencies tend to use a common mode choke because its easier to absorb parasitics. If you're trying to get significant high frequency noise reduction, the performance of a single section filter won't cover a lot of decades bandwidth no matter what you do.


If I needed significant broadband filtering from DC to Ghz, I would use a common mode choke and then caps (bulk, bypass, and RF) followed by a low dropout linear regulator to remove the lower part of the spectrum and then ferrite bead type chokes and bypass/RF caps to clean up the rest of the spectrum. There are ferrite blends that have a lot of parasitic resistance that make parts that are useless for tuned circuits and ideal for DC supply filtering. You want a choke with a low Q for a DC filter.


No comments:

Post a Comment

arduino - Can I use TI's cc2541 BLE as micro controller to perform operations/ processing instead of ATmega328P AU to save cost?

I am using arduino pro mini (which contains Atmega328p AU ) along with cc2541(HM-10) to process and transfer data over BLE to smartphone. I...