Saturday, 14 January 2017

voltage - What is more accurate definition of Ohm's law?


What is more accurate definition of Ohm's law and resistance? is it


$$R=\frac {V}{I}$$


or


$$R=\frac{dV}{dI}$$


This is doubt that developed in my mind during a class where professor derived power equation where he used second one for resistance in the derivation. I checked Wikipedia. They showed the first relation as accurate. Of course if the first relation is correct and resistance \$R\$ is constant, then we can use second relation. But what if resistance is not constant?


For a practical problem, suppose my voltage source is current dependent and is given by



$$V=I^2+2I$$


Then how will you find resistance of given circuit at a given value of current \$I\$?



Answer



This answer is probably inherently displeasing to the feeling of natural order for some :-) :


A law of nature is simply a statement of observed results under defined conditions.


Ohms law is essentially a statement that the ratio of the two two variables V & I is typically observed to remain approximately constant as the variables vary.


It is arguably saying the opposite of what it may seem - ie not so much
"R is the ratio between ..." but
it is more "if the ratio between V & I is constant then we call this constant resistance" and "this approximates typical behaviour of a significant proportion of real world products".


At any given moment R IS the ratio between V and I. If this ratio has changed then R has changed. So V/I never changes for specific values of V & I with all other conditions held constant, whereas dV/dI typically does change in the real world.



So R = V/I is an accurate statement
R = dV/dI is usually an approximation and
where it all falls apart it just means that the observation does not apply under thos e conditions.




That's woolier than I'd like but seems to convey what I'm trying to say. I hope :-).


No comments:

Post a Comment

arduino - Can I use TI's cc2541 BLE as micro controller to perform operations/ processing instead of ATmega328P AU to save cost?

I am using arduino pro mini (which contains Atmega328p AU ) along with cc2541(HM-10) to process and transfer data over BLE to smartphone. I...