As I understand it, both thermistors and thermocouples are temperature sensors. So what are the advantages/disadvantages of using one over the other to measure the temperature? What are the specific applications for either of the sensors?
Answer
Thermocouples:
- wide range of temperature sensing (Type T = -200-350°C; Type J = 95-760°C; Type K = 95-1260°C; other types go to even higher temperatures)
- can be very accurate
- sensing parameter = voltage generated by junctions at different temperatures
- thermocouple voltage is relatively low (4.3mV for Type T thermocouple with one end at 0 C, other at 100 C, so that's 43uV/C tempco)
- mostly linear
Thermistors:
- more narrow range of sensing (Quality Z thermistors spec'd at -55 to +150 C)
- sensing parameter = resistance
- usually very nonlinear
- NTC thermistors have a roughly exponential decrease in resistance with increasing temperature
- good for sensing small changes in temperature (unless you are careful in your signal conditioning, it's hard to use a thermistor accurately and with high resolution over more than a 50 C range).
- sensing circuit doesn't need amplification & is very simple (voltage divider with reference resistor tied to reference voltage usually is sufficient) – see my blog for more information about signal conditioning.
- accuracy is usually hard to get better than 1°C without calibration
No comments:
Post a Comment