Thursday, 9 February 2017

operational amplifier - Replacing tantalum capacitor with ceramic capacitor for Op Amps


I am trying to build non-inverting amplifier with certain op amp; THS3491



The datasheet is linked below.


http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/ths3491.pdf


On page 25, there is non-inverting configuration diagram.


enter image description here


And on page 35, there is guideline for decoupling capacitors


enter image description here


It says "Use larger tantalum decoupling capacitors (with a value of 6.8uF or more) that are effective at lower freqeuncies..."


I had such bad experience with tantalum capacitors, so I wanted to avoid using these.


Is it okay to replace tantalum capacitors with ceramic ones?


Searching over the StackExchange, I found several pages with similar problem;



Tantalum capacitors vs. ceramic capacitors


MLCC vs Tantalum: For Decoupling, input to regulator and ripple reduction


The answer was that it is okay to use ceramic, but not so sure because I am dealing with Op Amps. I searched more;


http://www.dataweek.co.za/news.aspx?pklnewsid=27008


In above website, they recommend to use ceramic over tantalum, since ceramic capacitors have more advantages over tantalum.


But, is it okay to replace tantalum with ceramic capacitors?



Answer



In most circuits, yes. And in your circuit this would be fine.


Capacitance is just capacitance and ceramic MLCCs capacitance values have increased quite a bit in the last few decades, leading to a much wider applicability (and the ongoing production shortage).


But you must be aware of a couple of caveats that are mostly exclusive to ceramics:





  • In some circuits capacitive ESR is a needed part of the circuit, a minimum value is expected and ceramics tend to have extremely low ESR. In some cases this can lead to instability and oscillations. Of particular concern would be the input of switching DC-DC converters and long DC supply cables that can be connected live.




  • MLCCs tend to have very strong voltage dependencies. These can lose 60% or more of their capacitance value under DC bias. In addition to the capacitive loss, this is a non-linear behavior that can be of concern in some circuits.




  • MLCCs ceramics are piezoelectric. Any vibration or temperature gradients can cause noise to be injected into the circuit. And, in some switching applications, you will actually hear the buzzing in the capacitors which can lead to mechanical failures.





No comments:

Post a Comment

arduino - Can I use TI's cc2541 BLE as micro controller to perform operations/ processing instead of ATmega328P AU to save cost?

I am using arduino pro mini (which contains Atmega328p AU ) along with cc2541(HM-10) to process and transfer data over BLE to smartphone. I...