Tuesday, 19 February 2019

manufacturing - Why are we still using resistors with %5 tolerance while they can even manufacture a 14.318182MHz crystal?



Year is 2012 and I can only find %5-tol resistors in the local market. They can make transistors at molecular scale, they can manufacture 14.318182MHz crystals, they can place trillions of flip-flops inside a memory chip.


Then why don't they start manufacturing %0.01-tol resistors? Is resistor manufacturing a more difficult job compared to the ones I mentioned above? What is the reason for still manufacturing %10-tol and %5-tol resistors?


(I'm asking this because I learned that the following circuit may not work because the resistor values may differ greatly from the rated ones.)


Schematic



Answer



One more point worth considering: Maybe there's a problem with the local market?


In my local market, I have no problems getting 1% resistors and sometimes there's a larger choice of 1% resistors compared to 5% resistors. It's not always the question of can it be made but will people buy it too. Maybe your merchants for some reason believe that not enough people will buy 1% resistors, so they don't bother having them in stock (Basically what's it worth to them to have a part in stock when others sell well enough?) or they may be just lazy*. Maybe very small amount of people actually expressed their desire to use such resistors. Maybe people are so used to 5% resistors that they don't feel the need buy more expensive resistors since they haven't actually had the chance to see them in action.


Perhaps there's a non-obvious way for those resistors to enter your local market? Here where I am, we have companies that specialize in obtaining components which nobody else has in stock in amounts low enough so that working directly with foreign distributor would be too expensive.


Since we know that 1% and better resistors are commonly available in some parts of the world, the reason could be something specific to your market.


*For the end a short story about human nature possibly related to this issue: I lived in another country for several years and found there a brand of printers that I like very much. When I returned to my homeland, I noticed that nobody even heard of that brand. It so happened that I stumbled upon the office of the distributor for that brand and talked to them for a while. I was basically told that they're not expanding since they already have enough customers to sustain their company and that they don't want to bother having more customers than it's necessary for them to continue existing.



No comments:

Post a Comment

arduino - Can I use TI's cc2541 BLE as micro controller to perform operations/ processing instead of ATmega328P AU to save cost?

I am using arduino pro mini (which contains Atmega328p AU ) along with cc2541(HM-10) to process and transfer data over BLE to smartphone. I...